California ERC market report · 1993

Bay Area ERC sales, 1993

10 recorded sales, from the district's own records.

Home / Reports / 1993 / Bay Area

In 1993 CARB's statewide §40709.5 report lists 10 priced ERC sales in Bay Area AQMD. NOx: 3 recorded sales at a median of $9,460 per ton ($6,500–$20,000); ROG / VOC: 4 recorded sales at a median of $9,235 per ton ($6,500–$9,977); PM10: 1 recorded sale at a median of $10,000 per ton; SOx: 2 recorded sales at a median of $5,500 per ton. Prices are per ton as recorded by the district and reported to CARB.

1993 by pollutant

PollutantMedian $/tRangenSource
NOx$9,460$6,500–$20,0003CARB report, sale by sale
ROG / VOC$9,235$6,500–$9,9774CARB report, sale by sale
PM10$10,000$10,000–$10,0001CARB report, sale by sale
SOx$5,500$5,500–$5,5002CARB report, sale by sale

NOx in Bay Area, every recorded year

$4k$19k$38k199319992003200920142017202020231993: $9k ($7k–$20k)1995: $8k ($8k–$8k)1996: $8k ($8k–$8k)1999: $8k ($4k–$14k)2000: $11k ($6k–$15k)2001: $15k ($7k–$38k)2003: $25k ($25k–$25k)2006: $11k ($10k–$13k)2007: $10k ($6k–$30k)2009: $14k ($11k–$17k)2010: $11k ($10k–$13k)2013: $13k ($13k–$13k)2014: $15k ($15k–$15k)2015: $15k ($12k–$15k)2016: $15k ($15k–$15k)2017: $14k ($9k–$18k)2018: $14k ($6k–$20k)2019: $14k ($12k–$30k)2020: $17k ($9k–$24k)2021: $20k ($20k–$25k)2022: $22k ($8k–$31k)2023: $29k ($23k–$29k)

Each line runs from the lowest to the highest recorded price that year; the dot is the median.

ROG / VOC in Bay Area, every recorded year

$450$22k$43k199319962000200320062009201220152018202120221993: $9k ($7k–$10k)1994: $7k ($6k–$20k)1995: $7k ($450–$14k)1996: $7k ($7k–$8k)1997: $5k ($5k–$5k)1999: $6k ($4k–$8k)2000: $8k ($5k–$16k)2001: $23k ($6k–$43k)2002: $20k ($12k–$34k)2003: $11k ($7k–$14k)2004: $11k ($9k–$12k)2005: $7k ($7k–$7k)2006: $10k ($9k–$12k)2007: $12k ($957–$17k)2008: $13k ($10k–$17k)2009: $11k ($7k–$13k)2010: $8k ($7k–$11k)2011: $8k ($8k–$9k)2012: $8k ($8k–$8k)2013: $7k ($6k–$8k)2014: $7k ($1k–$10k)2015: $7k ($7k–$8k)2016: $7k ($5k–$18k)2017: $6k ($5k–$7k)2018: $9k ($5k–$9k)2019: $6k ($6k–$9k)2020: $6k ($5k–$8k)2021: $8k ($7k–$9k)2022: $9k ($9k–$10k)

Each line runs from the lowest to the highest recorded price that year; the dot is the median.

PM10 in Bay Area, every recorded year

$6k$28k$57k1993199419992000200120022006200720102016201920221993: $10k ($10k–$10k)1994: $22k ($22k–$22k)1999: $9k ($8k–$10k)2000: $10k ($6k–$13k)2001: $20k ($9k–$30k)2002: $35k ($12k–$50k)2006: $33k ($16k–$37k)2007: $21k ($10k–$57k)2010: $30k ($30k–$30k)2016: $20k ($20k–$20k)2019: $25k ($25k–$25k)2022: $20k ($20k–$20k)

Each line runs from the lowest to the highest recorded price that year; the dot is the median.

SOx in Bay Area, every recorded year

$100$1k$10k199319992001200620092013201820221993: $6k ($6k–$6k)1994: $6k ($6k–$6k)1999: $4k ($2k–$6k)2000: $10k ($6k–$13k)2001: $1k ($1k–$1k)2002: $8k ($8k–$8k)2006: $8k ($7k–$10k)2007: $9k ($7k–$14k)2009: $11k ($11k–$11k)2010: $15k ($15k–$15k)2013: $10k ($10k–$10k)2016: $20k ($20k–$20k)2018: $6k ($6k–$6k)2022: $10k ($51–$20k)

Each line runs from the lowest to the highest recorded price that year; the dot is the median; the scale is logarithmic because prices span more than a hundredfold.

The 1993 sales

DatePollutantAmount$/tCertificate
1993NOx17.3 tons$9,460Not provided
1993NOx144.9 tons$20,000Not provided
1993NOx1.9 tons$6,500Not provided
1993SOx43.9 tons$5,500Not provided
1993SOx55 tons$5,500Not provided
1993PM9.28 tons$10,000Not provided
1993HC7.33 tons$6,500Not provided
1993HC5 tons$9,600Not provided
1993HC3.1 tons$8,870Not provided
1993HC61.7 tons$9,977Not provided

Source: CARB Emission Reduction Offset Transaction Cost Summary Report for 1999 (HSC §40709.5). Every row, with its source, is in the transaction download. · 1994